Yo, Dudes and Dudettes! My blog has moved!

You should be automatically redirected in about 6 seconds. If not, surf yourself over to
and update your bookmarks. And keep it real!

Get Wine Smarties! The 1WineDude Tasting Guide is NOW AVAILABLE!

How to Fix the Broken U.S. Wine Shipping System

I know what you're thinking, after reading the title of this post.

"Is the Dude about to go on yet another tirade about the PLCB? Okay, okay, they suck - we get it already..."

Well... the answer is "Yes." Sort of. I'm about to go on a bit of a tirade about the wine shipping laws not just of Pennsylvania, but also of WA, ID, AZ, CO, KS, MN, IA, WI, MI, IN, KY, GA, FL, SC, NC, NY, VT, CT, RI, and IL (pending review of currently proposed legislation).

The state of affairs of wine shipping laws in those states is almost hopelessly broken. Notice I say "almost hopelessly." That's because I've thought of a way to fix it. Let's break it down...

I say broken because those states have laws on the books that restrict the free trade of inter-state wine sales - a practice deemed unconstitutional at the federal (and for some also at the state) level. For the most part, these states are trying to protect state-run monopoly businesses that would be handed their own jock straps in the free market if, say, a big buyer like Costco were permitted to sell and ship wines directly to consumers in those states. The state run operations add extra cost while limiting value and selection - because they are monopolies, they don't need to compete on the basis of price or service. If individual consumer rights, or the best interests of local state wineries get in the way of their monopoly profits, those citizens are simply disregarded - even if the states' supreme courts have ruled against those practices. So, they make billions, pay big bucks to lobbyists to protect their position, and the state governments (for the most part) turn a blind eye to it all (probably because of the huge windfall).

How to fix this mess? Simple. Here's a 2-step process of playing politics that could turn the tide. The thing to keep in mind is that politics is almost always a numbers game. And it almost always involves you (the people getting screwed) getting off your keesters and getting active.

  1. Stop buying wine from the state. I mean it. Don't buy wine from your state-run liquor store. What will this do? It will reduce the windfall (remember the part about this being a numbers game?). No profits, no windfall. No windfall, no paying lobbyists to turn the tide of free trade legislation. No lobbyists, no deceit-filled battles to block the spread of capitalism to the wine shipping business.

    Disclaimer: I'm not advocating you breaking the law - and to be honest, your state's liquor laws are so convoluted you probably violated them already if you took any cough medicine this year. Anyway, I don't care where you get your wine, as long as it's not from a state-run monopoly. If you are lucky enough to live near a bordering state that does sell wine through the free market economy... well, I'm just saying that you might have alternatives.

  2. Write your state legislators. This is still a numbers game, because far fewer people actually do this than you'd think. So, if you flood your state legislators with correspondence, eventually they will question whether the tide needs to turn against the monopolies. Especially if you followed step 1 (politicians likely won't stand by a sinking ship that is losing money) and indicate in your correspondence that you're a voter in good standing and any re-election bid support on your part will hinge on their demonstrated support of free trade.

    Fortunately, writing your state legislators is very easy. Head on over to FreeTheGrapes.org - they will find your legislators e-mail addresses for you, and give you a handy form-letter to send them (don't forget to add the re-election support part - politicians usually don't like losing their jobs).
Maybe this sounds unreasonable, overly-simplistic and ridiculous to you.

But ask yourself this:

Is it any more ridiculous than a business with cripplingly poor business models, that can't compete on the basis of service, selection, and price, making in excess of $1.5 billion dollars a year by hiding behind antiquated laws and charging you artificially high prices?

What if your state controlled your cell phone service that way? Or forced you to buy milk only from the state, even though it was stored improperly and cost 35% more than what your cousin, who lives in the next state over, pays for his family's milk (which he can buy from wherever he feels offers the best milk at the lowest price)? Or limited your selection of underwear to a handful of brands and sizes?

Or treated women's designer shoes the same way? (scary... that one might have the potential to drive Mrs. Dudette to kill)...

Sure, there's a big difference between "essential" goods like bread and luxury goods like designer fashions. But before you write off wine as an item that is fair play for regulation by the "pleasure police" (Robert Parker's term for the alcohol regulators in his home state of MD), don't forget that two of our founding fathers (the two widely regarded to have had the most raw intellectual horsepower, by the way) - Jefferson and Franklin - viewed wine as an essential life good, equal to water and bread in terms of necessity.

So... who's being unreasonable?


(images: blog.whathappensnow.com, wine.appellationamerica.com, ronalfy.com)


Susan said...

I live in New York and I am confused reading all the posts regarding the state wine laws. I don't know if living in New York I can purchase from an out of state retailer or winery directly legally nor do I know if I go to my neighborhood liquor store if I am supporting a law which is restricting free trade. It is all very confusing and also very state specific so many of the posts I read are specific to a state other than New York. I would like to find a site that would explain these confusing laws and let me know what wine buying options are available to me living in New York.

Anonymous said...

You need to get further West than Pennsylvania. Colorado is listed on your limited shipping, government liquor store list. Tain't true. We have NO problem shipping into Colorado on direct shipment from vineyards or internet sites and there is nary a guvamint store in sight.

Joe Roberts said...

Thanks for the comments, all!

SBerko9118 - Good luck! ;-) You amy want to check out http://lennthompson.typepad.com/lenndevours, which specializes in NY wines and may have some pertinent NY wine law info.

insane scribbler - check out my About page for the e-mail address and we can chat.

serendipity - I hear ya but it 'taint as open as you might think. Check out http://wineinstitute.shipcompliant.com/StateDetail.aspx?StateId=FC680839E0574DA182033600611C054B7


www.ifoods.tv said...

Hi There

Sorry for writing this in the comments but as I am compiling a list of all the food bloggers in the world it would take too long to find all the e mail addresses. I have 2 things that are of interest to food bloggers 1)The comphrehensive list of Food Bloggers from around the glode we have compiled at http://ifoods.tv/site/blog-links.jsp As this list is massive can you check if your blog is correctly linked and you are happy with it. Secondly we are offering food bloggers free advertising banners on www.iFoods.tv as part of a initiate to drive traffic to food blogs. Could you please email us if you wish to participate. Once again sorry for writing in the comments and hope to hear from you soon. Cheers

The Wine Messenger

International Wine Accessories